The beauty of Pakistan cricket is its ability to win a match from nowhere, but that beauty comes with a flaw—they can lose a match from a winning position and stun their fans and followers. Thankfully, the green shirts didn’t lose their mojo in the final of the ODI tri-series against Sri Lanka, and they finally clinched an ODI series trophy at home in a multi-team series.
Chasing 326 at Lahore’s Gaddafi Stadium, Pakistan won by three wickets against a spirited Sri Lankan side that had earlier chased 429 runs against England in the series. What made the victory even more special was that the players who didn’t get a chance to prove their mettle finally got their chance, proved themselves, and won the match for Pakistan.
They didn’t have to rely on old horses like Babar Azam and Mohammad Rizwan, who have damaged Pakistan Cricket so much that it would take years to return to normal. Because of them, Fakhar Zaman had to switch batting positions, lose his form, and then lose his place in the side; however, he came back strongly to score the trophy-winning century in the grand finale.
The middle order’s useful contributions and a late lower-order assault helped Pakistan pull off a challenging chase, not thanks to Babar Azam, who kept his final failure record intact by not even bothering to score. The newer players showed the world that Pakistan Cricket has talent, can rely on youngsters, and can play modern-day cricket, helping deliver a victory that might take Pakistan Cricket forward.
But victories, like defeats, should be analyzed honestly. A trophy can lift morale, but it should not obscure the problems that continue to affect Pakistan cricket. There were encouraging signs, some questionable decisions, and a few uncomfortable truths. If Pakistan is serious about building a stronger side, it must learn as much from this triumph as it would from a defeat.
The Good
The standout performers from the series were Arafat Minhas and Saad Baig. Both showed that Pakistan’s future need not depend on recycling the same familiar names.
Arafat Minhas was outstanding in the final, scoring 61 off just 31 balls and earning Player of the Series. His ability to shift a game’s momentum is exactly what Pakistan needs from a young all-rounder. He is not merely someone who can fill a spot in the playing eleven; he has the potential to be a match-winner.
Not only did he take six wickets in an innings and score a fifty in the same match, but he also kept his head down even when he wasn’t used until the 29th over in the very next match, only to end up with two more wickets. Pakistan must give him opportunities, patience, and a clear role rather than expect him to deliver miracles every time he plays.
Saad Baig was equally impressive, earning praise from all quarters for both his glovework and his batting. Before his 74 in the final, he played important knocks in the round-robin league, showing Muhammad Rizwan’s followers that a wicketkeeper can bat at number four and increase the scoring at the same time. In all his innings, he showed composure and an understanding of what the situation demanded, unlike Khawaja Nafay or Usman Khan, who were neither the best wicketkeepers nor the best batters.
One must also mention Hasan Nawaz, whose steady approach over the past few months has been instrumental to Pakistan’s success. Since his innings in the Commonwealth Games final, the opposition has taken him seriously, and he proved his worth in the big finale with an unbeaten 37. He is the kind of batter Pakistan should be investing in, while Maaz Sadaqat deserves attention for his ability to contribute with the ball as well. As captain, Shaheen Afridi must recognize that the team has options beyond the players he is most comfortable with.
The lesson from the series is simple: Pakistan has young players waiting for opportunities. They should be given them.
The Bad
Shaheen Afridi may have taken more wickets than any other pacer in the Pakistan side, become the first captain to win a tri-series at home, and bring a smile to Pakistan Cricket supporters’ faces, but his captaincy remained flawed. He showed preferential treatment to certain players, especially those he has played with for a long time, namely Shadab Khan. The former leg-break bowler isn’t even an international-standard bowler anymore, yet he gets to play as an all-rounder, and his place in the team should be questioned.
Yes, he managed to win the match against England with a record-breaking ODI century, but his primary role is bowling, and he failed big time. No one should forget that Shadab was given a chance to prove his bowling prowess in the match against England, where Shaheen Shah Afridi deliberately kept Arafat Minhas out of the attack to prove that his dear friend can still deliver. That decision nearly cost the match as Ben Duckett completed his century, only to be dismissed by Arafat Minhas, who had spent the first half of the innings as a fielder.
In a country where talented bowlers like Sufyan Muqeem are warming the bench, and Arafat Minhas is receiving second-rate treatment despite his heroics in the last match, watching Shadab play on reputation is frustrating. Pakistan cannot afford to select players based on reputation, past achievements, or personal comfort. If Shadab is not delivering consistently, his position should be reviewed like any other cricketer’s. A team cannot move forward when it judges some players by a different standard.
The selection of Faheem Ashraf over Abrar Ahmed in the final raised further questions. In a match where Pakistan needed its best players, leaving out a specialist spinner considered among the best in the world was hard to understand. Whether it was to keep Shadab’s position intact because he wasn’t in the playing XI or for another reason remains unclear. The team management must explain the reasoning behind such choices rather than expect supporters to accept every selection without question.
There is also the question of Sahibzada Farhan. Why recall him from Nepal if he was only going to warm the bench? Was his inclusion a genuine selection decision, or was it intended to pressure Fakhar Zaman? If a player is considered good enough to be recalled, he should at least be given a meaningful opportunity. Pakistan cricket needs consistency in selection, but that consistency should not mean protecting established names. It should mean applying the same standards to everyone.
The Ugly
Babar Azam remains the biggest question mark for this talented, developing side. There is no denying what he has achieved for Pakistan, but past performances cannot guarantee his place now. His recent contributions have not been enough to justify the unquestioning faith he still receives. Yes, he is the captain of the Test side and was reportedly interested in captaining the limited-overs sides as well, but his form over the past five years has damaged not only his reputation but also his statistical record.
He was once considered one of the world’s top five batters, but today he stands nowhere because he lacks the will to learn, change, and improve. Even the best batters in the world don’t disregard first-class cricket as Babar has, and unless he goes back to basics to improve, he must be kept out of international cricket. His approach has increasingly become a liability when the situation demands urgency. The team cannot keep building its batting plans around a player who doesn’t consistently deliver what the role requires.
This is not about dismissing his achievements or questioning his talent. It is about recognizing that international cricket is unforgiving and that every player, regardless of stature, must earn their place. If younger batters such as Hasan Nawaz and Saad Baig are expected to prove themselves, Babar should be held to the same standard. Pakistan has enough players waiting in the wings to make competition for places meaningful. The selectors must have the courage to make difficult decisions, even when those decisions involve the country’s most celebrated cricketers.
Winning the tri-series was a welcome achievement, and the players deserve credit. But one trophy cannot resolve years of inconsistent planning, questionable selections, and an overreliance on established names. Pakistan cricket is still at a crossroads. The real test will be whether the team management learns from this victory and has the courage to act on it.

