They say rewatching a film offers a comforting, predictable experience that reduces stress. That sounds like sound advice. But what about watching a movie about the making of a classic Hollywood film released more than fifty years ago? I Play Rocky proves that, if executed well, that experience can raise the bar, entertain fans, and give the audience something to remember.
Written by Peter Gamble and directed by Peter Farrelly, this biographical drama is based on Sylvester Stallone’s autobiography The Steps and on the documented struggle to make the first Rocky film, which launched the Italian Stallion as a contender.
Instead of following Sylvester Stallone’s journey to stardom, this film takes you through the hardships that helped him break into Hollywood, how his perseverance led him to star in his own screenplay, and the factors that made Rocky one of the most iconic films in Hollywood history.
I Play Rocky is entertaining, inspiring, and nostalgic all at once, and it shouldn’t be missed. Here are my top five reasons why I believe I Play Rocky deserves to be called the ultimate biopic of the year.
1. The perfect film about the making of a film!
Not many films about the making of another film are as interesting as the original. Some try to outshine the original, while others try to look too much like it, and both approaches fail. I Play Rocky, borrow the best elements from both, and succeed. It targets both audiences familiar with Rocky and those who aren’t, taking them on a journey in which an underdog actor, Sylvester Stallone, takes a stand for himself and makes a name for himself, just as his creation, Rocky Balboa, did on the big screen.
The film shows viewers the obstacles, compromises, disappointments, and determination that went into bringing the boxing drama to life. If you think watching a young actor—unrelated to Stallone—play the legend on screen is fascinating, think again. It reminds us that behind every success story are countless moments when things could have gone terribly wrong, but they didn’t.
2. You couldn’t get the casting more right!
Perfect casting is difficult to achieve, especially when a film is based on real people, most of whom are still alive and recognizable because of their work’s success. Yet I Play Rocky gets it remarkably right—not a single character feels miscast.
The film’s biggest draw is Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone, who not only talks and walks like the legendary action star but also dresses, behaves, and carries himself in ways that remind viewers of the young actor who wanted to play Rocky himself. His belief in his acting abilities is visible in his eyes from the moment he watches Muhammad Ali fight an unknown contender on TV, and the way his character embraces problems and provides solutions feels believable.
AnnaSophia Robb is perfect as his girlfriend, Sasha, who becomes his wife, and is portrayed as the support he needed during his struggling days. Even though Mrs. Stallone wasn’t visible on screen during the making of the film, her work as a photographer was incorporated into the screenplay as well. Watching Matt Dillon as Frank Stallone, the abusive father who never considered his son talented, is there, as is Jay Duplass, who plays director John G. Avildsen, who went on to direct The Karate Kid a decade later.
One must commend the makers for casting P.J. Byrne and Toby Kebbell as Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff, the producers of Rocky, since they looked more suited to the 1970s than anyone else. Their performance is on par with the rest of the characters, including Tracy Letts, who plays Sandy Maddox, a character that combines the many individuals who wanted a bigger star for the film but got an unknown who knew that belief in himself would be a box-office victory.
I Play Rocky is one of those rare occasions when you don’t find yourself questioning the casting. In fact, I cannot remember the last time I watched a biopic in which the casting felt this universally appropriate. Getting one important character right is an achievement; getting an entire ensemble right is something else altogether.
3. If you loved Rocky, you will love this even more!
The film doesn’t just recreate the making of a Hollywood classic; it makes the process itself feel like a cinematic adventure. The film’s conception, its completion in less than four days, and Stallone’s desire to play the role are all explored.
The art direction is top-notch as well; at times, when footage from the original classic is used alongside the latest, you can get confused about which is which. For example, this film shows how the iconic ice skating rink scene was filmed, and when the original scene appears, you will think twice about whether the one you just saw was the original or a recreation.
In short, for anyone who grew up watching Rocky, this film is a nostalgic treat. Bill Conti’s unforgettable theme music, the recreation of the iconic running sequence, and the bout between Rocky and Apollo Creed bring back memories of what made the original film so special.
4. Never a dull moment!
Just like the original film’s near-perfect execution, I Play Rocky never bores the audience. The only time you might check your watch is when the credits roll; that’s how intense this project is. Reading Sylvester Stallone’s memoir The Steps will give you an advantage, but you can read it afterward as well to understand the ‘Rocky’ start of the franchise.
It’s a good thing, if you think about it, that you don’t know what happened. The only thing you need to know about I Play Rocky is that it’s a film about the classic Rocky. Not knowing about the issues, roadblocks, and budgetary problems would be a blessing.
Even if you know what happened behind the scenes, the film never feels predictable. The storytelling maintains its momentum, and there is always something happening to keep the audience invested. For someone familiar with the book, it is especially satisfying to see those anecdotes brought to life in the best possible way.
5. Made by the people, for the people!
Agree to disagree, but there is a reason why I play Rocky will always rank higher than Michael on my list. First, it celebrates an event that doesn’t require the subject’s family’s direct involvement or endorsement.
Second, it does exactly what Michael Jackson’s sister, Janet, wanted: cast someone who isn’t related to the subject and let him shine. Anthony Ippolito’s acting chops were tested during the making of I Play Rocky, but he came out as someone who makes you believe he is Stallone, despite not being related to him.
The lead actor didn’t even meet Sylvester Stallone until the film’s premiere! That makes the achievement even more remarkable. The filmmakers managed to recreate an important chapter of Stallone’s life without relying on his personal participation, except for the parts he described in his memoirs.
Ultimately, I Play Rocky succeeds because it understands what audiences want from a biopic: a compelling story, convincing performances, emotional engagement, and entertainment. It doesn’t need to be a family-approved celebration or a glossy tribute to its subject.
It simply tells a great story about a man who refused to give up on his dream. And just like the original Rocky, it is a story worth cheering for.

